How to Compare Factory Quotes: What EXW, FOB, and DDP Leave Out

Two clothing quotes can only be compared when they cover the same costs. Here is what each common delivery term includes, what it leaves to you, and how to line up quotes fairly.

Two factory quotes for the same garment can only be compared after you put them on the same basis. The delivery term on each quote, such as EXW, FOB, or DDP, decides which costs the price includes and which ones you still have to pay. Quotes can also differ in what they assume about fabric, quantity, packaging, and samples. Convert every quote to the same delivery point and the same assumptions, and only then compare the totals.

What do EXW, FOB, and DDP mean?

They are Incoterms rules, standard trade terms published by the International Chamber of Commerce. The current version is Incoterms 2020. Each term defines where the seller's responsibility ends: who pays for each step of the journey, and when the risk of loss passes to the buyer.

TermSeller's price coversYou still pay for
EXW (Ex Works)The goods, ready for pickup at the factoryLoading, export clearance, freight, insurance, import duties, delivery
FOB (Free On Board)The goods, export clearance, and loading on board the ship at the named portOcean freight, insurance, import duties and fees, delivery from the US port
DDP (Delivered Duty Paid)The goods, freight, import clearance, duties, and delivery to the named placeUnloading, and any costs the seller left out

Other terms appear in quotes too. FCA (Free Carrier) is similar to FOB but ends when the goods are handed to your carrier, which suits container and air shipments. CIF adds ocean freight and insurance to the port of destination, but you still pay the import costs, and the risk passes to you once the goods are loaded at the port of shipment.

Always read the place named after the term. "FOB Shanghai" and "FOB Ho Chi Minh City" end at different ports, and "DDP Los Angeles" should name the exact address.

Why can't you compare an FOB quote with a DDP quote?

Because they cover different costs. A DDP quote includes freight, duties, and delivery. An FOB quote stops at the export port. The DDP price will almost always look higher, but it may be the cheaper option once you add your own freight and duty to the FOB price.

To compare, add the missing costs to the narrower quote. For an FOB quote, add ocean or air freight, insurance, US duties and customs fees, broker fees, and delivery to your address. Then compare totals at the same place: your door.

What else differs between quotes besides the delivery term?

Delivery terms are only one difference. Check each quote for these:

ItemWhat to check
FabricThe same fiber content, weight in GSM, and dyeing method in every quote
QuantityThe same quantity and the same split across colors and sizes
Trims and labelsWhether woven labels, hang tags, and custom trims are included or priced separately
DecorationWhether printing or embroidery is included, and in what size and number of colors
PackagingIndividual polybags, folding, carton marking
SamplesSample fees, how many samples, and whether fees are credited against the bulk order
Payment termsThe deposit and when the balance is due
Lead timeThe production time, and whether it starts from the order, the deposit, or sample approval
Price validityHow long the price holds, and whether it depends on fabric prices
ToleranceWhether you must accept a percentage more or fewer pieces than ordered

If a quote leaves an item out, ask. Don't assume it's included.

How do you line up quotes in practice?

Build one comparison sheet with a row per supplier and the same columns for every quote:

  1. Ask every supplier to quote on the same tech pack, version, quantity, and size split (what a quote request needs).
  2. Ask for the same delivery term from everyone, such as FOB at their nearest port, plus a DDP price if they offer one.
  3. For each FOB quote, get a freight estimate for that origin from your forwarder, and estimate duties using the current tariff rate (how to estimate landed cost).
  4. Add sample fees and any separate charges for labels, packaging, or decoration.
  5. Divide the total by the number of pieces to get a landed cost per piece.

The lowest unit price is often not the lowest landed cost. A factory farther from its port, or in a country with higher US tariffs, can lose its price advantage by the time the goods reach you.

Is DDP the easier choice for a small brand?

DDP is simpler: one price, and the supplier arranges shipping and customs. For a small first order, that convenience is real. Ask three questions before you accept it:

  • Who is the importer of record? That party is legally responsible to US customs for the entry.
  • How was the duty calculated? Ask for the tariff code used and the customs value declared.
  • Will you get the entry documents? Copies show what was declared and what was paid.

A DDP price well below what you calculate for FOB plus freight plus duty is a warning sign. The savings may come from an undervalued declaration, and the consequences of an incorrect entry can fall on the importer.

When does EXW make sense?

EXW gives you the most control and the most work. It can suit a buyer who already has a freight forwarder in the supplier's country. Under EXW the buyer is responsible for export clearance in the seller's country, which can be hard to arrange from abroad. For most small brands buying from overseas, FOB or FCA is the more practical starting point.

Sources